Objective Demographic changes have led to a higher incidence of C-2 fractures, especially in elderly patients. For patients with type II fractures, treatment remains controversial, as discussed by Anderson and D’Alonzo, due to the rising morbidity and mortality rates for any treatment. The aim of this study was to compare conservative and surgical management in patients with type II C-2 fractures regarding outcomes, complications, and the mortality rate.
Methods A retrospective analysis was performed of the medical records, X-rays, and/or computed tomography scans of patients ≥80 years of age with type II fractures who were admitted to our Department of Neurosurgery between January 1990 and December 2017. The success of treatment was evaluated 3 months after surgery.
Results In total, 125 patients were included, of whom 98 were treated surgically and 27 were treated conservatively. Surgical treatment was successful in 90.8% of cases, while conservative treatment was successful in 70.0%. The in-hospital mortality was 14.29% and the 3-month mortality was 27.8% in the surgical group, compared to 3.7% and 20% in the conservatively treated group. The in-hospital complication rate was 22.4% in the surgically treated patients and 7.4% in the conservatively treated patients.
Conclusion Surgical treatment of type II fractures seemed to be associated with higher success and complication rates than conservative treatment. Nevertheless, 3-month mortality was comparable in both groups. Therefore, we conclude that surgical treatment for type II fractures in elderly patients is superior to conservative management, although conservative treatment remains a valuable option in elderly patients with severe comorbidities.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Outcomes of early vs delayed surgical intervention in geriatric patients with cervical spinal fractures and spinal cord injuries Harry Marland, Arnav Barve, Jake M. McDonnell, Meadhbh Ni Mhiochain de Grae, Conor McNamee, Kielan V. Wilson, Stacey Darwish, Joseph S. Butler The Surgeon.2026; 24(3): 200. CrossRef
Does early surgical intervention for type II dens fractures improve survival in octogenarians? A propensity-matched analysis Ziam Khan, Kevin T. Kim, Parantap Patel, Timothy Chryssikos British Journal of Neurosurgery.2026; : 1. CrossRef
Cases and Controversies in Spine Trauma Katherine M. Bunch, Nathaniel Brooks, Wendell Lake, Bradley T. Schmidt, Daniel K. Resnick Neurosurgery Clinics of North America.2025; 36(1): 31. CrossRef
Ununited Mobile Odontoid Fracture: Clinical and Imaging Findings With Subsequent Management: A Case Report Inger K. Roug, Jane Cook, Vijay Kumar Pabbathi, John Andrew Radin Journal of Chiropractic Medicine.2025; 24(1-4): 402. CrossRef
Operative versus nonoperative management of type II odontoid fractures in the elderly: A systematic review and meta-analysis of comparative studies Guy Awad, Marc Boutros, Gebrane Abou Mjahed, Jad Bou Monsef Clinical Neurology and Neurosurgery.2025; 258: 109165. CrossRef
Risk factors for in-hospital mortality in geriatric patients aged 80 and older with axis fractures: a nationwide, cross-sectional analysis of concomitant injuries, comorbidities, and treatment strategies in 10,077 cases Maximilian Kerschbaum, Lisa Klute, Leopold Henssler, Markus Rupp, Volker Alt, Siegmund Lang European Spine Journal.2024; 33(1): 185. CrossRef
Evidence and Controversies in Geriatric Odontoid Fracture Management Brian C. Goh, Tariq Z. Issa, Yunsoo Lee, Alexander R. Vaccaro, Arjun S. Sebastian Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.2024; 32(2): e84. CrossRef
Assessing the Impact of Undiagnosed C1‒C2 Rotatory Subluxation in the Conservative Treatment of Odontoid Fractures Simon Diaz, Mejdeddine Al Barajraji, Victoria Dembour, Dominique Rothenfluh, Juan Barges-Coll World Neurosurgery.2024; 191: e723. CrossRef
Morbidity and mortality of traumatic cervical spinal cord injuries in a geriatric cohort Kielan V. Wilson, Jake M. McDonnell, Sandra O’Malley, Deirdre Lynch, Jeremie Larouche, Gráinne M. Cunniffe, Stacey Darwish, Seamus Morris, Joseph S. Butler Irish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -).2023; 192(4): 1719. CrossRef
Operative Versorgung der Typ2-Densfraktur bei >80 Jahren – Contra Claudius Thomé Die Wirbelsäule.2023; 7(01): 43. CrossRef
Geriatric Odontoid Fractures: Treatment Algorithms of the German Society for Orthopaedics and Trauma Based on Expert Consensus and a Systematic Review Georg Osterhoff, Matti Scholz, Alexander C. Disch, Sebastian Katscher, Ulrich J. A. Spiegl, Klaus John Schnake, Max J. Scheyerer Global Spine Journal.2023; 13(1_suppl): 13S. CrossRef
Type II Odontoid Fractures: Is the Anterior Screw a Good Solution for all Patients? A Case Series of 60 Consecutive Patients Fernando Luiz Rolemberg Dantas, François Dantas, Gustavo Agra Cariri, Antônio Carlos Vieira Caires, Marco Túlio Domingos Silva e Reis, Ricardo Vieira Botelho World Neurosurgery.2023; 176: e535. CrossRef
The optimal treatment of type II and III odontoid fractures in the elderly: an updated meta-analysis Jeroen G. J. Huybregts, Karma A. Barot, Camila Recio, Joanne Doucette, Rania A. Mekary, Carmen L. A. Vleggeert-Lankamp European Spine Journal.2023; 32(10): 3434. CrossRef
Morbidity and mortality related to type II odontoid fractures in octogenarians undergoing surgery: a retrospective study with 5 year follow up Pavlina Lenga, Gelo Gülec, Karl Kiening, Andreas W. Unterberg, Basem Ishak Frontiers in Medicine.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Risk factors for early mortality in elderly patients with unstable isolated C2 odontoid fracture treated with halo-vest or surgery Akira Honda, Yoichi Iizuka, Nobuaki Michihata, Kojiro Morita, Tokue Mieda, Eiji Takasawa, Sho Ishiwata, Yohei Kakuta, Yusuke Tomomatsu, Shunsuke Ito, Kazuhiro Inomata, Hiroki Matsui, Kiyohide Fushimi, Hideo Yasunaga, Hirotaka Chikuda Scientific Reports.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Odontoid fracture in geriatric patients — analysis of complications and outcome following conservative treatment vs. ventral and dorsal surgery Matthias K. Jung, Lukas Hörnig, Philipp Raisch, Paul A. Grützner, Michael Kreinest BMC Geriatrics.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Clinical features and early post-operative complications of isolated C2 odontoid fractures: a retrospective analysis using a national inpatient database in Japan Akira Honda, Nobuaki Michihata, Yoichi Iizuka, Tokue Mieda, Eiji Takasawa, Sho Ishiwata, Hiroki Matsui, Kiyohide Fushimi, Hideo Yasunaga, Hirotaka Chikuda European Spine Journal.2021; 30(12): 3631. CrossRef
Morbidity and Mortality in Patients over 90 Years of Age Following Posterior Stabilization for Acute Traumatic Odontoid Type II Fractures: A Retrospective Study with a Mean Follow-Up of Three Years Mohammed Issa, Karl L. Kiening, Andreas W. Unterberg, Moritz Scherer, Alexander Younsi, Stepan Fedorko, Rod J. Oskouian, Jens R. Chapman, Basem Ishak Journal of Clinical Medicine.2021; 10(17): 3780. CrossRef
Odontoid screw placement for Anderson type II odontoid fractures: how do duration from injury to surgery and clinical and radiological factors influence the union rate? A multicenter retrospective study Luca Ricciardi, Sokol Trungu, Alba Scerrati, Pasquale De Bonis, Oriela Rustemi, Mauro Mazzetto, Giorgio Lofrese, Francesco Cultrera, Cédric Y. Barrey, Alessandro Di Bartolomeo, Amedeo Piazza, Massimo Miscusi, Antonino Raco Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine.2021; 34(1): 27. CrossRef
One-year follow-up for type II odontoid process fractures in octogenarians: Is there a place for surgical management? Francois Borsotti, Daniele Starnoni, Timo Ecker, Juan Barges Coll Surgical Neurology International.2020; 11: 285. CrossRef
First
Prev
