WHY THIS ISSUE
Over the past decade, advances in endoscopic surgical technique and instrumentation, together with a rapidly expanding body of literature, have ensured that the difficulty in endoscopic spine surgery is no longer a shortage of published evidence. For nearly every question raised in this issue, pooled estimates, forest plots, and meta-analytic conclusions already abound. What that literature does not capture is how the operation comes to be chosen—in the clinic and at the console, by surgeons who have rendered the same decision many hundreds of times, yet whose reasoning seldom reaches a comparative trial. The gap this issue seeks to close is therefore one not of quantity but of kind: between the questions a randomized trial is equipped to answer and the questions a surgeon must in fact answer, one patient at a time.
The 7 debates that make up this issue were not selected at random. They are the questions that recur, year upon year, in the debate sessions of every major spine meeting. Several reflect how rapidly the field has advanced—uniportal versus biportal decompression, endoscopic decompression versus fusion for spondylolisthesis, and endoscopic interbody fusion measured against the established minimally invasive benchmark. Others are older controversies carried unresolved for more than a decade: inside-out versus outside-in transforaminal discectomy, and the interlaminar versus transforaminal approach to disc herniation. The remaining 2 set the endoscope directly against the microscope—in decompression for lumbar stenosis, and in posterior cervical foraminotomy.
To varying degrees, these questions resist resolution by the conventional randomized trial. For some, such as endoscopic decompression versus fusion, a classical trial is all but impossible: clinical equipoise rarely exists between them, and the demands of informed consent make random allocation difficult to defend. For others, such as interlaminar versus transforaminal discectomy, it is exceedingly difficult rather than impossible: the surgical corridor cannot be blinded, the learning curve confounds early comparison, and genuine equipoise seldom survives a surgeon’s training, although pragmatic or cluster-randomized designs may yet have a role. Across the set, the outcomes that distinguish the techniques often emerge only over years, so that awaiting the definitive conventional trial has, in practice, meant awaiting it indefinitely. This issue therefore adopts a different approach: each paper stages a structured debate—explicit advocacy for each position, closed by an explicit verdict—anchored in a structured international practice survey [
1-
7]. To our knowledge, the pairing of formal 2- and 3-sided debates with a large real-world survey across an entire themed issue represents a novel undertaking in the field.
Taken together, the 7 surveys drew upon more than 740 responses from participating spine surgeons—between 63 and 172 per debate—gathered across more than 40 countries worldwide, while the papers themselves were authored by 116 surgeons from 40 countries spanning 5 continents (
Fig. 1). Because the surveys were anonymous and were circulated through overlapping international networks, these figures constitute a cumulative response count and a broad international snapshot of reported practice among participating surgeons, rather than a representative census of global practice.
This issue speaks to a discipline taking stock of itself. A recent editorial has urged the forging of a new and shared consensus in endoscopic spine surgery [
8]; the field has achieved as much before, standardizing the nomenclature of these procedures through formal international consensus [
9]; and both its evidentiary foundation and its path forward are now themselves the subject of active appraisal [
10].
WHAT THE SURVEYS FOUND
A single principle runs through all 7 papers: each survey is read as a description of practice, not as a substitute for comparative effectiveness. The surgeons who answered a given survey —the panel for that debate—were, in every case, drawn largely from the endoscopic community, so that each panel leaned to some degree toward the endoscopic side of its argument; rather than conceal that imbalance as a limitation, each paper reports it openly, as a finding in its own right. Where such an endoscopy-weighted panel nonetheless declined to crown endoscopy the winner, that restraint carries particular weight. Across the 7 debates the same pattern recurred—broad agreement on patient selection and approach-related advantages, but none on the hard endpoints—and 2 verdicts warrant particular emphasis.
Uniportal versus biportal decompression is, at present, the most actively contested question in the field—the “portal wars” that preoccupy today’s meeting floors. Here the survey proves most instructive: with no clear difference in outcome demonstrated in the published literature, preference tracked the surgeon’s own platform rather than the pathology before them. The survey thus provides a real-world baseline against which a shared, evidence-based consensus can be built if the field is to move beyond this impasse—an aim articulated in a recent editorial [
8]—and a practical guide to the circumstances in which each platform represents the reasonable choice.
Endoscopic decompression versus fusion for spondylolisthesis illuminates, more clearly than any other debate, the proper role of the endoscope. That an endoscopy-experienced panel nonetheless routed unstable disease to fusion while reserving endoscopic decompression for stable, single-level disease is the clearest signal of the endoscope’s genuine value: not a universal replacement for fusion, but a tissue-sparing alternative that may spare a carefully selected patient the greater undertaking of arthrodesis—a direction whose comparative effectiveness and durability now merit dedicated study.
THE COMMON MESSAGE
Read together, the debates converge upon a single lesson that no individual meta-analysis delivers: in the questions that divide this field, the decisive variable is rarely the device itself, but rather the pathology before the surgeon and the platform—endoscopic or otherwise—in which the surgeon was trained. Where the panels found agreement across the divide, it concerned principles of patient selection and approach-related advantages—tissue preservation, visualization, and recovery. Where they would not agree, it concerned the hard endpoints—fusion reliability, durability, complications, and revision—which opinion cannot settle and which belong to trials we do not yet possess. That an endoscopy-weighted panel repeatedly declined to claim victory on precisely those endpoints is what lends the conditional conclusions their credibility. The result is less a verdict than a map: a delineation of where consensus is real and teachable now, and where genuine uncertainty lies and research must be funded.
OUTLOOK
The debate-and-survey format does not supplant the randomized trial; it is what may be done while that trial remains beyond reach, and a means of defining the trials worth designing. Each paper specifies the evidence that would alter its verdict—stratified cohorts, surgeon-experience thresholds, follow-up of 2 to 5 years, and rigorous cost-utility analysis. Should this issue succeed, its surveys will date quickly, overtaken by the very studies they call for—the most favorable outcome we might hope for—and the format itself may serve as a model for other unresolved debates in spine surgery. Until then, these 7 debates afford the field a transparent account of where its surgeons agree and where, in candor, they still do not know.
NOTES
-
Conflict of Interest
The author has nothing to disclose.
-
Acknowledgments
The author thanks the first and corresponding authors and the international contributors who argued each side in good faith, the many surgeons who responded to the surveys, and Editor-in-Chief Professor Inbo Han for championing a special issue of a kind the journal had not attempted before.
A large language model (Claude; Anthropic) was used to assist with drafting, structuring, and language editing of this editorial, and to render the data visualization in Fig. 1 from authorsupplied figures. The author reviewed and verified all text and data and takes full responsibility for the content of the manuscript.
Fig. 1.The international scope of the special issue. Seven debate papers drew 159 authorships from 116 surgeons in 40 countries across 5 continents, anchored by 741 survey responses from practicing spine surgeons worldwide. (A) Authors and participating countries per debate. (B) Unique authors and authorships by country. (C) Regional distribution of the 116 contributing authors. TELD, transforaminal endoscopic lumbar discectomy; ULBD, unilateral laminotomy for bilateral decompression; MIS-TLIF, minimally invasive transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion.
REFERENCES
- 1. Suvithayasiri S, Pedraza MC, Kwon WK, et al. Inside-out versus outside-in transforaminal endoscopic lumbar discectomy: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:950-68.
- 2. Pholprajug P, Ultarnpatumros T, Kavishwar RA, et al. Interlaminar versus transforaminal full-endoscopic lumbar discectomy for lumbar disc herniation: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:803-28.
- 3. Liang YH, Santipas B, Baranto A, et al. Endoscopic versus microscopic decompression for lumbar spinal stenosis: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:926-49.
- 4. Patel KK, Scherrer C, Kim JS, et al. Uniportal versus biportal endoscopic unilateral laminotomy for bilateral decompression in lumbar spinal stenosis: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:856-77.
- 5. Boonsirikamchai W, Jitpakdee K, Park DY, et al. Endoscopic lumbar interbody fusion versus minimally invasive transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:832-52.
- 6. Ambrosio L, Auron M, Farshad M, et al. Endoscopic decompression versus fusion for degenerative lumbar spondylolisthesis: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:904-25.
- 7. Giordan E, Chavalparit P, Fournier JY, et al. Uniportal endoscopic versus biportal endoscopic versus microscopic/tubular posterior cervical foraminotomy: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:881-903.
- 8. Kim JS, Chavalparit P. Editorial: beyond the portal wars–forging a new consensus in endoscopic spine surgery. Global Spine J 2026;16:9-10.
- 9. Hofstetter CP, Ahn Y, Choi G, et al. AOSpine consensus paper on nomenclature for working-channel endoscopic spinal procedures. Global Spine J 2020;10(2 Suppl):111S-121S.
- 10. Kim MT, Lee S, Goh GS, et al. Endoscopic spine surgery: evidence maturity and the path forward in the United States. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2026 Oct 9. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.26.00630. [Epub].
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
